Sag Harbor Properties for Rent

87 found
Private Watermill Apartment - Winter Rental
1611 Deerfield rd
Water Mill
Hamptons
April 1-30th 2027
$2,500
January 1-31st 2027
$2,500
March 1-31st 2027
$2,500
November 1-30th 2027
$2,500
1 bed
1 bath
SAG HARBOR VILLAGE COMPOUND ON AN ACRE
268 Madison st
Sag Harbor
Hamptons
7 bed
5½ bath
Newly Renovated Summer Retreat!
139 Merchants path
Wainscott
Hamptons
5 bed
4½ bath
Sag Harbor 4BR 4.5BA with Pool & Picturesque Surroundings!
Sag Harbor
Hamptons
4 bed
4½ bath
Bridgehampton Post Modern Home
33 Woodruff ln
Bridgehampton
Hamptons
4 bed
2½ bath
Sag Harbor NEW Renovation!
146 Stoney Hill rd
Sag Harbor
Hamptons
4 bed
3 bath
Sag Harbor Home With Bay Views!
34 Rolling hl
Sag Harbor
Hamptons
4 bed
2½ bath
Stunning 4 Bedroom Home in Sag Harbor with Tennis!
108 Six Pole hwy
Sag Harbor
Hamptons
September 1-30th 2027
$40,000
4 bed
6 bath
Sag Harbor 5 Bedroom in Beach Community
Sag Harbor
Hamptons
5 bed
3½ bath
87 found

Our Offices

Southampton, NY

25 Nugent Street, Southampton, NY 11968, USA

Geoff Gifkins

Regional Manager

hamptonsinfo@nestseekers.com

Phone 631-287-9260

East Hampton, NY

46 Newtown Lane, East Hampton , NY 11937

Geoff Gifkins

Regional Manager

hamptonsinfo@nestseekers.com

Phone 631.324.1050

Bridgehampton, NY

2415 Montauk Highway PO Box 742, Bridgehampton, NY 11932

Geoff Gifkins

Regional Manager

hamptonsinfo@nestseekers.com

Phone 631-353-3427

Bridgehampton Office

2415 Montauk Hwy

Geoff Gifkins

Regional Manager

hamptonsinfo@nestseekers.com

Phone 631.353.3427

Westhampton Beach, NY

118 Main Street Westhampton Beach, NY 11978

Geoff Gifkins

Regional Manager

westhampton@nestseekers.com

Phone 631-259-4330

Sag Harbor, NY

138 Main Street, Suite 2 - 6, PO Box 3228, Sag Harbor, NY 11963

Geoff Gifkins

Regional Manager

hamptonsinfo@nestseekers.com

Phone 631.458.1045

Quogue

4 Midland St, Quogue, NY 11959 PO Box 1681

Geoff Gifkins

Regional Manager

hamptonsinfo@nestseekers.com

Phone 631-354-3547

Welcome to my Sag Harbor Hamptons Neighborhood Guide! Prepare to be enchanted by the beauty and charm of this historic village. Sag Harbor is a vibrant and charming bayfront village in the Hamptons, known for its mix of intellectuals, writers, local families, and nautically-inclined residents. T

Search results may include listings from the following third parties
Long Island MLS